Legacy Pie Co
Breads & Baked Goods CPFM 2026 LFM 2025 LFM 2026 Sweets & Confections Local Pantry
About
Established in 1929, we’ve proven that if pie is for special days, every day is for pie. What began as one family, and one perfect cherry pie has become a 100-year mission to master and re-master the most amazing recipes with every generation that goes by. We build on baking traditions and branch out with special takes on classic favorites so you and yours can experience joyful, new tastes that take you to delicious, new places every time.
News & Media

How Legacy Pie Co. Is Building on Generations of Baking Expertise

Some pies are sweet, such as the flagship tart cherry or caramel-drizzled bourbon apple, while savory versions include hearty ingredients like bison and mushrooms.

Legacy Pie Co: Four Generations Evolving from 1929 Wisconsin Pie Stand to Denver Bakery

> Tracing its roots to 1929 when Katherine Lehnert opened a pie and cider stand in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, the family business relocated to Colorado in the 1950s with Elias's grandparents. After operating as Colorado Cherry Co. across northern Colorado—including locations in Loveland, Lyons, and the Stanley Hotel in Estes Park—fourth-generation owner Elias Lehnert (29) and his wife Rachel opened a Denver location on Tennyson Street in November 2020, rebranding as Legacy Pie Co. Elias reflects on the transformation: 'It's exciting for us. The business has such a good foundation. We're excited to continue to run it' and 'to improve it and build upon it and take it to the next level.' The Denver venture represents a strategic shift from tourism-focused shops to urban neighborhood markets, growing from two employees to 11 full-time workers (20 during peak seasons) and selling approximately 80,000 pies by mid-November 2022.
Locations
Business
4000 Tennyson St,
Denver, CO, 80212
United States
News & Media

How Legacy Pie Co. Is Building on Generations of Baking Expertise

Some pies are sweet, such as the flagship tart cherry or caramel-drizzled bourbon apple, while savory versions include hearty ingredients like bison and mushrooms.

Legacy Pie Co: Four Generations Evolving from 1929 Wisconsin Pie Stand to Denver Bakery

> Tracing its roots to 1929 when Katherine Lehnert opened a pie and cider stand in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, the family business relocated to Colorado in the 1950s with Elias's grandparents. After operating as Colorado Cherry Co. across northern Colorado—including locations in Loveland, Lyons, and the Stanley Hotel in Estes Park—fourth-generation owner Elias Lehnert (29) and his wife Rachel opened a Denver location on Tennyson Street in November 2020, rebranding as Legacy Pie Co. Elias reflects on the transformation: 'It's exciting for us. The business has such a good foundation. We're excited to continue to run it' and 'to improve it and build upon it and take it to the next level.' The Denver venture represents a strategic shift from tourism-focused shops to urban neighborhood markets, growing from two employees to 11 full-time workers (20 during peak seasons) and selling approximately 80,000 pies by mid-November 2022.
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.